Choosing a mattress for a rental property can feel like an impossible task. Too soft, and guests will complain. Too firm, and you risk a bad review.
When it comes to buying a new mattress, there are countless factors that need to be considered. In today’s world, there are options for every body (literally), but that makes the process of choosing a mattress very overwhelming.
The first thing most people think about is comfort. But what does “comfort” really mean? How do you choose something that works for a wide range of guests staying at your rental? Should you go with memory foam? A hybrid? Innerspring? A cooling mattress? Soft, medium, or firm? Do you need a box spring? And how much are you willing to spend?
My head is spinning just typing those questions out.
Luckily, I’ve done the research and compared dozens of mattresses. Ultimately I found a mattress that’s a reliable, crowd-pleasing choice — and one that won’t break the bank.
The winner is: The Signature Design Chime Hybrid Bed by Ashley Furniture.
Quick specs:
- Type: Hybrid
- Firmness: Medium
- Ships: Bed-in-a-box
- Expansion: 48 hours – 1 week
- Best for: Most sleep styles
- Price for Queen size (as of winter 2026): $315
More detail:
- It has the perfect blend of softness and support
- The price feels like a steal for the quality
- It is a hybrid innerspring mattress, meaning it has Iraditional coils to provide support and longevity, with layers of memory foam for comfort
- It is technically listed as “medium” support, which is typically a good choice for a rental property
- It ships in a box, making delivery and set up easy
- Good movement isolation, which is great for couples sleeping in the same bed
We have this mattress in our own home so we can personally attest to its comfort. If you’re looking to upgrade your Airbnb or rental property mattress, this is a fantastic blend of comfort and affordability.
If you’re looking for the best bedding to go with your new mattress, check out my other blog post on my favorite bedding here.
Disclaimer: This post contains an affiliate link. If you choose to purchase through this link, I truly appreciate your support!
